I Remember Clifford Chord Progression & Harmonic Analysis | Niels Dalgaard

Benny Golson · 1957 · E♭ major · AABA, 32 bars

I Remember Clifford — Chord Progression & Harmonic Analysis

Under the elegiac melody the bass climbs by half steps, A♭ to A to B♭ to B to C, with a diminished chord filling each gap. It is the clearest example in the repertoire of passing diminished chords doing structural work.

Secondary dominants

Chord progression

Analyzed excerpt

Section: A1 · Bars 1–4

Ebmaj7 G7 | Abmaj7 Adim7 | Bb7 Bdim7 | Cm7

The books behind this page

Every one of these tunes is assembled out of the same handful of harmonic resources. Jazz Harmony is those resources, explained in the order in which they build on each other.

See all the books
Completely free Free edition · All instruments

The Jazz Roadmap Lite

The sixteen stages of the roadmap, a paragraph each, and which book develops every one of them. Twelve pages, fifteen minutes — enough to know where you are standing and what comes next. Download the free PDF →

Play I Remember Clifford in JamShed

The whole form, not just these bars: JamShed’s trio — double bass, drums and piano — plays it with you at the tempo and in the key you choose. Loop the bars that trip you up, mute the instrument you play, share the link.

▶ Open in JamShed

Harmonic analysis

Key
E♭ major
Tonal center
Eb
Confidence
Low
Chords analysed
7

Read in E♭ major, the key of the tune. Taken on its own, with nothing around it, this excerpt is just as easy to hear in C minor — a few bars are often not enough to fix a tonic, and that ambiguity is a real property of the music rather than a gap in the analysis.

ChordRoman numeralFunctionWhat it is doingConfidence
Ebmaj7ITonicEbmaj7 is the tonic of Eb. It is where the progression is at rest.High
G7V7/viDominantG7 is functioning as V7/vi: a secondary dominant. It is the dominant of C, not of the home key, so it borrows the pull of a V-I and points it at vi instead.Low
Abmaj7IVPredominantAbmaj7 is the IV chord of Eb: subdominant. It moves away from the tonic without creating the pull of a dominant.High
Adim7vii°7/VDominantAdim7 is a leading-tone diminished seventh resolving to Bb7. It is F7 with the root removed and a b9 in its place, which is why it pulls like a dominant. Also readable as #iv°7.Medium
Bb7V7DominantBb7 is the dominant of Eb. Its third and seventh form a tritone, and that tritone is what makes the tonic feel due.High
Bdim7vii°7/viDominantBdim7 is a leading-tone diminished seventh resolving to Cm7. It is G7 with the root removed and a b9 in its place, which is why it pulls like a dominant. Also readable as bvi°7.Medium
Cm7viTonicCm7 is the vi chord — the relative minor. It shares three notes with the tonic and often replaces it.High

High, medium and low next to each numeral are judgements about musical context, not probabilities. A low rating marks a bar that can honestly be read more than one way. How the ratings are decided →

The complete analysis of I Remember Clifford — every chord of the whole form, with its Roman numeral and its ii–V–Is marked on the chart — is in JamShed with the Practice Pass, ready to print. Open it in JamShed →

Why this example matters

Against a tonic of E♭ major the passage numbers as I – V7/vi – IV – vii°7/V – V7 – vii°7/vi – vi. Inside those 7 chords there is at least one secondary dominant and a diminished chord used as a connector. Strip it to two notes per chord, the third and the seventh, and play it under tempo. G7 gives you B and F; follow that pair from chord to chord and the voice leading becomes audible in a way the root motion never makes it. Once you can hear it here, it is hard to miss in Stella by Starlight, How High the Moon and Ornithology.

How the rest of I Remember Clifford goes

Thirty-two bars, AABA, usually preceded by a short written introduction. The A section is the excerpt’s chromatic climb in the bass, followed by a chain of secondary ii–Vs; the bridge is a series of minor ii–Vs that delays the return of the tonic as long as possible. The density of the changes is high for a ballad, which is why it is often played slowly enough for every passing chord to register.

I Remember Clifford on record

Benny Golson wrote it in 1956 after the death of Clifford Brown, who was killed in a car accident at twenty-five. Lee Morgan recorded it in 1957 and Art Blakey’s Jazz Messengers, with Golson and Morgan, played it often; it became the standard jazz elegy, and a lyric was later added by Jon Hendricks.

Analyze this progression

Load the progression and start altering it. Every edit is re-read from scratch, so you can test a hunch about one chord without rewriting the rest.

Open in Jazz Harmony Analyzer →

Related

← All 129 standards