It Had to Be You Chord Progression & Harmonic Analysis | Niels Dalgaard

Isham Jones · 1924 · G major · AABA, 32 bars

It Had to Be You — Chord Progression & Harmonic Analysis

The tonic sits for two bars and then hands the next six to a chain of secondary dominants walking the cycle back to V. Only the first chord is diatonic, and the song still sounds like the most natural in the world.

Secondary dominants

Chord progression

Analyzed excerpt

Section: A1 · Bars 1–8

G | G | E7 | E7 | A7 | A7 | A7 | D7

This is a short excerpt, not the full chart. The composition dates from 1924 and is old enough that it is very likely in the public domain in the United States, which is why the excerpt runs longer here — but copyright status varies by territory and by edition, so treat that as context, not as legal advice.

The books behind this page

Every one of these tunes is assembled out of the same handful of harmonic resources. Jazz Harmony is those resources, explained in the order in which they build on each other.

Harmonic analysis

Key
G major
Tonal center
G
Confidence
Low
Chords analysed
8

Read in G major, the key of the tune. Taken on its own, with nothing around it, this excerpt is just as easy to hear in D major — a few bars are often not enough to fix a tonic, and that ambiguity is a real property of the music rather than a gap in the analysis.

ChordRoman numeralFunctionWhat it is doingConfidence
GITonicG is the tonic of G. It is where the progression is at rest.High
GITonicG is the tonic of G. It is where the progression is at rest.High
E7V7/iiDominantE7 is functioning as V7/ii: a secondary dominant. It is the dominant of A, not of the home key, so it borrows the pull of a V-I and points it at ii instead.Low
E7V7/iiDominantE7 is functioning as V7/ii: a secondary dominant. It is the dominant of A, not of the home key, so it borrows the pull of a V-I and points it at ii instead.High
A7V7/VDominantA7 is functioning as V7/V: a secondary dominant. It is the dominant of D, not of the home key, so it borrows the pull of a V-I and points it at V instead.Low
A7V7/VDominantA7 is functioning as V7/V: a secondary dominant. It is the dominant of D, not of the home key, so it borrows the pull of a V-I and points it at V instead.Low
A7V7/VDominantA7 is functioning as V7/V: a secondary dominant. It is the dominant of D, not of the home key, so it borrows the pull of a V-I and points it at V instead.High
D7V7DominantD7 is the dominant of G. Its third and seventh form a tritone, and that tritone is what makes the tonic feel due.High

What the analyzer found in it

half cadenceD7

The progression stops on the dominant of G — a half cadence. It is unfinished on purpose.

High, medium and low next to each numeral are judgements about musical context, not probabilities. A low rating marks a bar that can honestly be read more than one way. How the ratings are decided →

Why this example matters

Read in G major, these bars come out as I – V7/ii – V7/V – V7. Inside those 8 chords there is at least one secondary dominant. The shortest way in is a two-voice reduction: third and seventh only, slowly. E7 contributes G# and D, and where that pair resolves is the whole story of the passage. You will meet the same move again in Stella by Starlight, How High the Moon and Ornithology, transposed and at a different pace.

How the rest of It Had to Be You goes

A thirty-two-bar song whose A sections move through secondary dominants in a regular, almost predictable rhythm — one temporary destination per two bars — before resolving home. The bridge provides contrast by slowing that rate rather than by changing key dramatically. It is one of the friendliest standards for a singer because the melody sits in a narrow range and the harmony never surprises, and one of the least demanding for a rhythm section for the same reasons.

It Had to Be You on record

Isham Jones wrote it in 1924 with lyricist Gus Kahn. It has had an unusually long second life through film — it appears prominently in When Harry Met Sally and Casablanca among others — which keeps it familiar to audiences who do not otherwise know the repertoire. That familiarity makes it a reliable choice for a set that has to reach a general room.

Analyze this progression

The excerpt is loaded and editable. Swap a chord for its tritone substitute, delete the preparation, borrow one from the parallel minor, and watch which numerals change and which do not.

Open in Jazz Harmony Analyzer →

Related

← All 100 standards