Gerald Marks & Seymour Simons · 1931 · C major · ABAC, 32 bars
Two secondary dominants in a row, and neither goes where the theory book says it should. E7 aims at Am and lands on A7 instead; A7 then does resolve, to Dm. The first one is a link in a chain, not a cadence.
Analyzed excerpt
Section: A · Bars 1–8
C | C | E7 | E7 | A7 | A7 | Dm7 | Dm7
This is a short excerpt quoted for analysis, not the full chart, and this composition is very likely still in copyright. Published versions and recordings disagree with each other about the rest of the tune, and often about these bars too.
Every one of these tunes is assembled out of the same handful of harmonic resources. Jazz Harmony is those resources, explained in the order in which they build on each other.
Read in C major, the key of the tune. Taken on its own, with nothing around it, this excerpt is just as easy to hear in D minor — a few bars are often not enough to fix a tonic, and that ambiguity is a real property of the music rather than a gap in the analysis.
| Chord | Roman numeral | Function | What it is doing | Confidence |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| C | I | Tonic | C is the tonic of C. It is where the progression is at rest. | High |
| C | I | Tonic | C is the tonic of C. It is where the progression is at rest. | High |
| E7 | V7/vi | Dominant | E7 is functioning as V7/vi: a secondary dominant. It is the dominant of A, not of the home key, so it borrows the pull of a V-I and points it at vi instead. | Low |
| E7 | V7/vi | Dominant | E7 is functioning as V7/vi: a secondary dominant. It is the dominant of A, not of the home key, so it borrows the pull of a V-I and points it at vi instead. | High |
| A7 | V7/ii | Dominant | A7 is functioning as V7/ii: a secondary dominant. It is the dominant of D, not of the home key, so it borrows the pull of a V-I and points it at ii instead. | Low |
| A7 | V7/ii | Dominant | A7 is functioning as V7/ii: a secondary dominant. It is the dominant of D, not of the home key, so it borrows the pull of a V-I and points it at ii instead. | High |
| Dm7 | ii | Predominant | Dm7 is the ii chord of C: the classic predominant. It prepares the dominant and almost always moves to it. | High |
| Dm7 | ii | Predominant | Dm7 is the ii chord of C: the classic predominant. It prepares the dominant and almost always moves to it. | High |
High, medium and low next to each numeral are judgements about musical context, not probabilities. A low rating marks a bar that can honestly be read more than one way. How the ratings are decided →
In C major the excerpt reads I – V7/vi – V7/ii – ii. Inside those 8 chords there is at least one secondary dominant. Play it slowly with only two voices — the third and seventh of each chord. In E7 those are Ab and D, and watching where that pair goes next tells you more about the progression than the root movement does. The same device turns up in Stella by Starlight, How High the Moon and Ornithology, in other keys and at other tempos.
The A sections work outward from the tonic through a series of secondary dominants, each one reached by a leap rather than by step, and then find their way home — the harmonic motion is wider than in most songs of its date but entirely functional. It is a favourite for teaching because a student can name every chord’s function without ambiguity, and a favourite at sessions because the melody is short enough to state and get out of.
Written in 1931 by Gerald Marks and Seymour Simons. Billie Holiday recorded it several times and her readings are the ones most often studied for phrasing — she consistently places the melody behind the beat in a way that has proved almost impossible to notate. Frank Sinatra’s versions took it in the opposite direction, brighter and on top of the beat, and the two approaches still divide performances of the tune.
Take these bars into the analyzer and interfere with them. The fastest way to learn what a chord was doing is to remove it and read what the analysis says instead.
What this device is, and the other standards in the library that use it.
Read →Victor Young · 1944 · B♭ major
Chord progression →Morgan Lewis · 1940 · G major
Chord progression →Charlie Parker · 1946 · G major
Chord progression →The families every standard is assembled from, with examples from the library.
Read →